This blog is a compendium to our current book project, Ethics and Religion in the Age of Social Media: Digital Proverbs for Responsible Citizens. The book, which we refer to as Digital Proverbs, is now available in e-book, paperback, and hardcover versions from Routledge!
The premise of the current book project is that popular forms of digital media, insofar as they reflect the idiosyncratic culture of Silicon Valley, tend to amplify socioeconomic inequality and other forms of social injustice. Our key argument is that digital platforms encode a set of ideological biases that we call the “moral catechism of Silicon Valley.” This catechism falsely equates technological capacities with specific human virtues, for example, equating information with wisdom and transparency with authenticity.
To develop digital platforms that enhance—rather than undermine—a just and sustainable democratic politics, we must maintain a clear distinction between technical capacities and the capacity for human virtue. Thus we outline a set of guiding principles or “proverbs” aimed at fostering a more humane digital environment, specifically:
- Information is not wisdom
- Transparency is not authenticity
- Convergence is not integrity
- Processing is not judgment
- Storage is not memory
Similar distinctions, such as the notion that connectivity is not intimacy, are also worthy of exploration. The five proverbs we offer are not exhaustive, but a starting point for a broader conversation.
To be clear, we acknowledge that technical affordances such as information processing and data storage are clearly related to the achievement of human virtues like wisdom, judgment, and memory. But on their own they cannot guarantee the achievement of such virtues—let alone replace them. By explicating these distinctions, and by addressing their implications in consultation with technical and policy experts, our book offers specific corrective strategies to address the structural and ideological biases of current platform architectures, algorithms, user policies, advertising models, and regulatory frameworks.
The interdisciplinary nature of this book, and its inclusion of examples from countries around the globe, will appeal to scholars in American Studies, Communication Studies, Media Studies, Journalism, Religious Studies, and Political Science. In addition, media critics (including lay and professional journalists) will find the book helpful in thinking about political and media issues in new ways. We envision the book as having the type of broad accessibility and appeal enjoyed by media-focused volumes like Jaron Lanier’s You Are Not a Gadget, Douglas Rushkoff’s Program or be Programmed, Nicholas Carr’s The Shallows: What the Internet is Doing to Our Brains, and Evgeny Morozov’s To Save Everything, Click Here. Through our diverse approach, we avoid political and religious partisanship and in our call for normative technologies we fully embrace the potential benefits of emerging technologies.

While our engagement with virtue ethics highlights the risks and challenges posed by emerging technologies—and therefore serves as a call to resist and transform the media environment we encounter—we refuse to adopt an attitude of cynicism and despair about the nature of commercial media. Through the forward-looking thrust of our approach, we intend to demonstrate that critical engagement with digital culture is essentially a hopeful endeavor.
The strategies we outline, derived from a set of simple proverbs, may yet usher in an era of digital humanism—one in which our technologies truly enhance the quality of political leadership and civic engagement.